Nothing But Truth: Encouraging Honest Patient Disclosure on Tough Topics

Originally published on Association for Patient Experience

How much alcohol do you drink each week?
Do we need to do an STD test today?
Have you been feeling depressed?
Are you taking your medication every day?
Does your family have enough to eat?

Did you flinch when thinking about how you’d answer any of these questions?

One of the first obstacles to improving health outcomes is getting an honest assessment of someone’s current behaviors and barriers to change. There are many reasons why either the patient or the provider might not be able to have a frank and accurate conversation.

Why are these conversations so difficult?

On the patient side:
  • It can be difficult for people to share sensitive information. They may be embarrassed to admit “bad” behavior, especially with respect to topics like smoking, drinking, or sexual activity.
  • A related phenomenon is social desirability. People want to please providers with the “right” answers, so they may not admit they’ve skipped medication doses or indulged in multiple martinis. They may not even admit these behaviors to themselves!
  • Sometimes people feel embarrassment, shame, or failure from their behaviors.
  • Or they may not understand critical information the provider needs and unintentionally omit or misrepresent something.

On the provider side:
There’s pressure to move quickly through a visit and document specific information for reimbursement. Time pressure forces providers to focus on the most physically pressing issues a patient has, which can sometimes overlook the root causes of health problems. Depression and social isolation, for example, are highly correlated with poor cardiac health and stroke incidence, but may not fall within the realm of a typical provider conversation.

And unfortunately, most providers do not receive training in skilled communication as part of their medical education, so they may not have the skills to elicit honest and meaningful responses from reluctant patients.

Provider communication skills are critical not just for the content of conversations, but also for the non-verbal responses that flavor them. Human beings in general are incredibly sensitive to nonverbal cues like facial expressions and tones of voice, and can easily detect disapproval or other negative emotions. Even a provider who is trying to express acceptance and encourage disclosure may reveal a negative response through nonverbal behaviors. To avoid this, providers need an awareness of their nonverbal behaviors and practice in controlling them.

Consider Amy’s recent experience:
At a recent wellness visit, being aware of the above issues in patient communication, Amy decided to be as forthright as possible. When the doctor asked how much she drinks in a typical week, Amy offered an honest response, knowing it was more than clinically recommended. But the doctor’s reaction was much more negative than Amy anticipated; although her drinking exceeds guidelines, it’s not outside of social norms. The doctor paused, and sat up straighter. Her facial expression turned very stern. Then, she told Amy that behavior was incredibly unhealthy and reviewed the clinical guidelines for alcohol. The conversation completely changed in tone, and in return for her honesty, Amy felt uncomfortable.

A physician friend later told Amy that she automatically does mental multiplication for any self-report data to correct for patient under-reporting. Amy’s doctor may have thought she was drinking much more than she confessed and reacted to that larger number. So even though Amy attempted to give the best possible information, the doctor’s reaction discouraged future disclosures.

How can we encourage honest disclosure?

If you're in the provider seat, you have an opportunity to help your patients feel normal and safe. When you ask questions about potentially sensitive topics, let patients know they’re not the only ones who face these challenges. This also creates a cue that you’re not going to scold them or be disappointed in them. Try prefacing your question with normalizing statements, such as:

“A lot of people I talk to have trouble taking medication…”

Read the full article on Association for Patient Experience.


By: Amy Bucher

Want to offer your customers a better experience?

Let's work together: Contact Us Today

Contributed by:
Amy Bucher Behavior Change Design Director   Contact Amy

Newsletter Sign Up

Mad*Pow HQ

27 Congress Street
Portsmouth, NH 03801

Office: 603.436.7177
Fax: 603.386.6608


179 Lincoln Street
Boston, MA 02111

Office: 617.426.7177


Complete Sale Inquiry Form


Sales: solutions
Press: communications

Get in Touch